TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Senate’s unprofitable constitution review – Punch

The Citizen by The Citizen
September 16, 2020
in Public Affairs
A A
0
Senate passes bills to establish Maritime University, two others
22
SHARES
734
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Indifferent to the enormous socioeconomic and political waves threatening Nigeria’s corporate existence, the Senate has embarked on another unprofitable jamboree to review the 1999 Constitution. An imprudent exercise, it is economically wasteful, frivolous and completely out of tune with the current political realities. Instead, the National Assembly should deepen democracy and cultivate federalism by intensifying legislative work on specific Acts, including repealing the schismatic aspects of the Exclusive Legislative List and passing a worthwhile version of the Petroleum Industry Bill.

No constitution is perfect, least of all Nigeria’s 1999 Constitution. It was cobbled together by the military as it retreated from the civil space in 1999. Periodically, this ingrained tackiness induces agitations for amendments. Most notably, it instigated the amendment of sections 144 and 145 (commonly referred to as the Doctrine of Necessity) during the medical crisis that nearly consumed the country under the Umaru Yar’Adua administration in 2010. The modest amendments to the Electoral Act cannot also be discounted, but other efforts to rework the constitution have failed.

The fresh endeavour being promoted by the Ahmed Lawan-led Senate is the fifth attempt by the federal parliament since the return to civil rule in 1999. Previous efforts resembled jamborees, with the result predictably unpalatable. The current attempt will not be different.

Just after the Ninth National Assembly took office in June 2019, it floated the idea of reviewing the constitution, just like the preceding NASS did – and failed woefully. In February, Senate President, Lawan, inaugurated a 56-man committee headed by his deputy, Ovie Omo-Agege, for the exercise. The committee has been at it, though the coronavirus pandemic necessitated a hiatus. On resumption, the committee has received over 40 memoranda on the areas the lobbyists want amended.

Equally, there has been a touch of controversy. Different political groups, particularly the Afenifere, the Ohanaeze Ndigbo, the Pan Niger Delta Forum, the Middle Belt Forum, the Yoruba Summit Group and the Northern Elders Forum have flatly rejected the idea. To them, the Senate is headed in the wrong direction, describing the review as a waste of resources. They have a strong point.

A broad constitution review might be a bridge too far for the parliament. The NASS was established to make laws for peace and good governance; it misses the point and diverts from this by taking on the job of a constituent assembly of the people. The NASS cannot do that. If it does, it is legislating extinction for itself.

In reality, amending the Nigerian constitution is a cumbersome enterprise. Only a broad buy-in by the critical segments of society can guarantee success. A tip: the President, Major General Muhammadu Buhari (retd.), refused his assent to the amendments of the Electoral Act 2010 on four separate occasions in the run-up to the 2019 polls. Each time, Buhari repudiated the amendments, NASS bowed to his caprices. At the end of the day, the law, incidentally aimed among others at legalising the Smart Card Reader and the use of the Permanent Voter Card, could not sail through. This is just one stakeholder. Now again, the Senate has yet to secure the agreement of others before embarking on its journey to nowhere.

Besides, Section 9 of the constitution makes the review tedious. Accordingly, an amendment can only go through after it is passed by two-thirds majority of both houses of the National Assembly, and approved by the resolution of the two-thirds of the (36) state Houses of Assembly. This is a long process, and public funds would have been needlessly wasted. In the previous fruitless exercises, the committees toured the states at great cost to the treasury, but all the efforts came to nothing.

Nigeria is falling apart – economically, politically and socially – and all the NASS can do is to make a mockery of constitution review. All the same, there are lessons from other federal states. Since the United States constitution came into existence in 1787, it has been amended only 27 times. Part of the amendments centred on a variety of rights ranging from freedom of speech to the right to vote. According to the Parliament of Australia records, only eight amendments have been made to that country’s constitution over the time: single changes in 1906, 1910, 1928, 1946 and 1967; and three changes in 1977. Even at that, Nigeria’s 1999 Constitution is a document in travesty as it did not derive its authority from the people.

At this critical juncture, the main responsibility of the National Assembly is to amend the specific areas that are easy to fix. It should immediately repeal the Railway Act 1955, modify the Electoral Act 2010, and expunge Section 3, sub-section 6 (and First Schedule Part I and Part II) of the constitution to allow state governments control over local governments, as is the standard practice in federal countries. By now, NASS should have prescribed “the terms and conditions” for any Nigerian citizen to inspect the asset declarations of public office holders as stated in paragraph 3(c), Part I, Third Schedule.

There are enough documents, including the 2014 National Political Conference report, to fall back on in returning Nigeria to a true federation. Fundamental to this is the devolution of powers or restructuring. This should be the main agenda of the parliament. States should be accorded considerable autonomy. Put bluntly, the basis of Nigeria’s existence should be fiscal federalism. The current arrangements in which the Federal Government controls the resources from the states and shares it out is unjust, a recipe for the current schism in the polity. Thus, there should be resource control, as it was in the First Republic.

In a federal state, there is no hiding from state police. NASS should repeal the subsisting model, where the shorthanded federal police have been shamed by rampant insecurity and grant the federating units the power to run their police forces. By now, states should be able to generate their own electricity, control admissions to educational institutions, stamp duties, and run prisons, railways, insurance and business name registration.

Indeed, Nigeria needs an entirely new constitution which can only come through the mechanism of restructuring. Comparative experience demonstrates a range of processes to draft and adopt a new constitution. Certainly, this is not the job for the National Assembly. Citizens, rights groups and activists should step up the agitation for a truly competitive federal polity, not one where indolence, sharing and consumption trump commonsense, productivity and merit.

Share9Tweet6Share2
Previous Post

Time to reopen the economy – Thisday

Next Post

Coronavirus vaccine may be ready for public in November – China

Related Posts

Avoidable deaths from container-laden trucks – Punch
Public Affairs

Avoidable deaths from container-laden trucks – Punch

February 2, 2023
COVID-19: Security operatives foil attempted jailbreak in Kaduna
Public Affairs

Governors should act on death row inmates – Punch

February 1, 2023
Electoral Act Amendment bill: Senators threaten to override Buhari as governors back President
Latest News

State assemblies right to reject LG autonomy – Punch

January 31, 2023
AMCON denies bid to seize Dangote refinery over debts
Public Affairs

Refineries’ privatisation solution to current mess – Punch

January 27, 2023
Gunmen shoot traveller dead, burn vehicle in Enugu
Public Affairs

Targeted killing of clerics condemnable – Punch

January 26, 2023
I’m focused on my job, it’s God that anoints leaders – Emefiele
Public Affairs

Uncertainty over Emefiele bad for economy – Punch

January 25, 2023
Next Post
AstraZeneca, Oxford pause trial of COVID-19 vaccine

Coronavirus vaccine may be ready for public in November – China

Aubameyang wins award for September

Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang: Arsenal captain signs new three-year contract

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Rousing the electorate from apathy – Vanguard

Elder statesman, Idatto Uzairue village Monarch-in-Waiting, Mallam Jibril Adamu Oshonebo, cautions politicians against heating up polity

by admin
January 28, 2023
0

...

AUN matriculates new students for Spring 2023 semester

AUN matriculates new students for Spring 2023 semester

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

...

CIVIC calls for probe into deadly airstrike in Nasarawa State

CIVIC calls for probe into deadly airstrike in Nasarawa State

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

...

Labour flares governors as states reject LG autonomy

Labour flares governors as states reject LG autonomy

by admin
January 25, 2023
0

...

ODDITIES

Nigerian kills compatriot in South Africa

Hoodlum stabs funeral guest for dating ex-wife

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

Why I married my daughter’s boyfriend – Kano woman

Why I married my daughter’s boyfriend – Kano woman

by admin
January 25, 2023
0

Family rejects old naira notes as bride price in Niger State

Family rejects old naira notes as bride price in Niger State

by admin
January 25, 2023
0

State of the States

Akeredolu brokers peace in Ondo community after 4-year crisis

Allow states to determine workers’ salaries, control resources, pay taxes to FG – Akeredolu advises

by admin
February 2, 2023
0

...

Edo PDP suspends Obaseki, Shaibu’s loyalists

Edo strengthens delivery of primary healthcare, to upgrade 55 PHCs

by admin
January 29, 2023
0

...

Osun guber: Supreme Court dismisses case against Adeleke

Gov. Adeleke hails overwhelming rejection of tribunal verdict by Osun people

by admin
January 29, 2023
0

...

Gov. Makinde signs €50m MoU with France for healthcare, education

Gov. Makinde signs €50m MoU with France for healthcare, education

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

...

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
UK licenses 266 Nigerian doctors in two months

UK licenses 266 Nigerian doctors in two months

August 3, 2022
Military will not rest until Book Haram is annihilated, says Army Chief

Shake-up in army

January 8, 2023
May Edochie finally speaks about husband’s second wife

I will not be cajoled into accepting polygamy, says May Edochie

December 24, 2022
Why I didn’t remarry — Patience Ozokwo

Why I didn’t remarry — Patience Ozokwo

January 20, 2023

Air Peace begins operations, offers airfare to Armed Forces personnel

170

Diezani breaks silence, reveals side of story in 3-part exclusive interview

26

FG’s N4trn contractual debts under Jonathan – National Mirror

21

2015: Washington Post condemns Jonathan for campaign slogan

20
Pope receives Merkel on farewell visit to Rome

Pope Mass in South Sudan: Pontiff urges people to reject ‘venom of hatred’

February 5, 2023
Prince Harry gets new job as tech start-up executive

How I took Prince Harry’s virginity, 40-year-old woman claims

February 5, 2023
Osimhen won’t be fit for AFCON, says surgeon

Man Utd, Chelsea, PSG battle to sign Osimhen

February 5, 2023
Elections: All police officers due for retirement must exit service – PSC

PSC appoints three DIGs, suspends CPs promotion

February 5, 2023

GLOBAL NEWS

Pope receives Merkel on farewell visit to Rome

Pope Mass in South Sudan: Pontiff urges people to reject ‘venom of hatred’

by The Citizen
February 5, 2023
0

...

Prince Harry gets new job as tech start-up executive

How I took Prince Harry’s virginity, 40-year-old woman claims

by The Citizen
February 5, 2023
0

...

Corporate America cuts off contributions to Trump-supporting Republican lawmakers

How Nigerian pastor’s wife was shot 12 times in US

by The Citizen
February 5, 2023
0

...

Sanctions: Iran offers discount on oil, gas to Asian market

Iran blames Israel for Isfahan drone attack, warning of revenge

by admin
February 2, 2023
0

...

Russian plane lands in US to pick diplomats expelled for espionage

West aiming to destroy Russia – Moscow

by The Citizen
February 2, 2023
0

...

EDITORIAL REVIEW

Avoidable deaths from container-laden trucks – Punch

Avoidable deaths from container-laden trucks – Punch

by admin
February 2, 2023
0

COVID-19: Security operatives foil attempted jailbreak in Kaduna

Governors should act on death row inmates – Punch

by admin
February 1, 2023
0

Electoral Act Amendment bill: Senators threaten to override Buhari as governors back President

State assemblies right to reject LG autonomy – Punch

by The Citizen
January 31, 2023
0

AMCON denies bid to seize Dangote refinery over debts

Refineries’ privatisation solution to current mess – Punch

by admin
January 27, 2023
0

Gunmen shoot traveller dead, burn vehicle in Enugu

Targeted killing of clerics condemnable – Punch

by admin
January 26, 2023
0

Opinion

Russia bans Facebook, Instagram platforms

Social media and solutions to political apathy

by admin
February 2, 2023
0

...

Understanding the Sheriff Oborevwori brand

Understanding the Sheriff Oborevwori brand

by admin
January 25, 2023
0

...

Gunmen attack FC Ifeanyi Ubah in Kogi

VIP protection: Advocating for mandatory bullet-proof vehicle for armed police escort

by admin
January 24, 2023
0

...

20 Years after, Alumni, community rally support for AUN Schools’ Improvement Project

20 Years after, Alumni, community rally support for AUN Schools’ Improvement Project

by admin
January 20, 2023
0

...

  • UK licenses 266 Nigerian doctors in two months

    UK licenses 266 Nigerian doctors in two months

    113 shares
    Share 45 Tweet 28
  • Shake-up in army

    59 shares
    Share 24 Tweet 15
  • I will not be cajoled into accepting polygamy, says May Edochie

    51 shares
    Share 20 Tweet 13
  • Why I didn’t remarry — Patience Ozokwo

    47 shares
    Share 19 Tweet 12
  • NNPC slashes petrol price for marketers to ease scarcity

    40 shares
    Share 16 Tweet 10
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2022 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2022 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.