TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Supreme Court frees Saraki on false assets declaration charge

The Citizen by The Citizen
July 7 2018
in Headlines, Latest News
A A
0
Supreme Court frees Saraki on false assets declaration charge

The Supreme Court has dismissed the charge of false assets declaration brought against the Senate President, Bukola Saraki, before the Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT).

Justice Centus Chima Nweze, in a lead judgment of a five-man panel, upheld Saraki’s appeal, set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal on the grounds that the prosecution failed to prove its case.

The Court of Appeal had, in a December 12, 2017judgement, held that the prosecution established a prima facie case against Saraki on three out of the 18 counts contained in the charge and ordered him to enter defence in relation to the three counts.

The apex court dismissed the entire charge and held that the prosecution failed to discharge its responsibility of proving its case.

The apex court upheld the June 14, 2017 ruling of the CCT, which freed Saraki. It was of the view that all the evidence presented by the prosecution were hear-say evidence and therefore not admissible.

The Supreme Court noted that the witnesses that were vital to the prosecution’s case, who would have provided direct evidence were not called.

The court, after discharging Saraki, proceeded to also dismiss the cross-appeal filed by the prosecution.

Other members of the panel were Justices Dattijo Mohammed, John Okoro, Amina Augie and Ejembi Eko.

In his lead judgment, with which the other four justices agreed, Justice Nweze faulted the prosecution for not appealing  the tribunal’s finding, to the effect that the evidence led by its (prosecution’s) witnesses were hearsay evidence, which are not admissible and cannot be accorded probative value.

Nweze also faulted the Appeal Court for partially voiding the decision of the CCT, by which it (Appeal Court), restored three out of the 18 counts contained in the original charge against Saraki. The CCT had dismissed the entire charge.

Nweze was of the view that the documentary evidence,  including Saraki’s assets declaration forms and his bank statements, tendered by the prosecution, amounted to documentary hearsay, because the witnesses, through whom the prosecution tendered them, we not the makers.

Nweze said: “Surely, the hearsay evidence of PW1 (EFCC operative) cannot by any stretch of logic move into the direct evidence of PW4 (Saraki’s account officer).

“What is more is that the hearsay evidence of PW1, the building block of of PW4, having been declared inadmissible, cannot be the basis of conclusion that the prima facie case has been made out in Counts 4, 5 and 6.”

Nweze said the Appeal Court was right in  agreeing with the CCT on the point that “practically, all the material evidence produced by the prosecution witnesses was hearsay. The actual person or persons or authorities who have knowledge about the facts sought to be proved were not called to testify before the tribunal.

“In all, from my intimate reading of pages 2323, 2325 and 2341 (of the record of appeal), I have only one observation to make.

“The lower court was caught up in an analytical mix-up, the mix-up that occasioned the inexcusable conclusion that a prima facie case has been made out with regard to counts 4, 5 and 6.

“This cannot be, since the same lower court has dismissed the testimonies of the witnesses as hearsay.

“I, therefore, take the view that having regard to the negative and unpleasant comments of the lower court on the probative value of the testimonies of PW1(see pages 2329, 2331, 2332 and 2333, Volume 5 supra), PW2 in pages 2334, 2335 and 2336, Volume 5, PW3 (see pages 2325, 2326, 2334; and PW4, whose testimony was woven around the inadmissible evidence of PW1, the lower court’s view that the prosecution made out a prima facie case in counts 4, 5 and 6 was a juridical equivalence of a forensic somersault.

“Such an approach which speaks ill about our jurisprudence is clearly unsupportable.

“For this court to agree with the lower court will be to supplant the constitutional provision of proving the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt.

“This court cannot lend its juridical stature and acclaimed eminence to such a caricature of justice.

“I, therefore, make bold to say that the lower court was in grave error when in the absence of material evidence no matter how slight ‘linking the defendant to the commission of the offences charged’ yet proceeded to hold that the prosecution was only able to establish prima facie against the defendant in Counts 4,5and 6. That cannot be.

“Against this background, therefore, I have the duty to vacate the judgment of the lower court.

“In its place, I find and hold that from the testimonies of the four prosecution witnesses, the prosecution failed to make a prima facie case against the appellant.

“I, therefore, in the penchant command of section 302 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act enter an order discharging the appellant.

“Accordingly, I restore the ruling of the trial tribunal in favour of the appellant. Appeal allowed. The appellant is discharged,” Nweze said.

Previous Post

Guber tussle: Ugwuanyi wins at Supreme Court as apex court awards N1m cost against Eze

Next Post

Alleged corruption: Nigerians don’t give accused people benefit of the doubt – Babachir Lawal, former SGF

Related Posts

Simon Ekpa regains freedom in Finland after sentence reduction
Latest News

Simon Ekpa regains freedom in Finland after sentence reduction

November 18 2026
2027: Tinubu repackages 2023 campaign promises in new manifesto
Headlines

Tinubu offers Nigerians ₦100m housing loans at 9.75% interest

November 18 2026
BREAKING: WAEC releases 2024 WASSCE results
Latest News

WAEC opens registration for 2027 WASSCE

November 18 2026
2027: Tinubu repackages 2023 campaign promises in new manifesto
Headlines

2027: Tinubu repackages 2023 campaign promises in new manifesto

November 12 2026
Tinubu gifts N100m to each victorious Flamingos player
Headlines

Tinubu gifts N100m to each victorious Flamingos player

November 11 2026
NFF Crisis: Tinubu orders comprehensive reform of Nigerian football
Headlines

‎Economy: Whoever says fuel subsidy will return is lying – Tinubu

November 10 2026
Next Post
Alleged corruption: Nigerians don’t give accused people benefit of the doubt – Babachir Lawal, former SGF

Alleged corruption: Nigerians don’t give accused people benefit of the doubt – Babachir Lawal, former SGF

Insecurity worse under Buhari than Jonathan – Sheikh Gumi

Insecurity worse under Buhari than Jonathan – Sheikh Gumi

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

by The Editor
October 21 2026
0

...

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

by The Editor
September 16 2026
0

...

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

by The Editor
August 30 2026
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Enugu APC releases updated campaign council list

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

by The Editor
October 22 2026
0

...

ODDITIES

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

by The Editor
November 5 2026
0

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

by The Editor
October 26 2026
0

GLOBAL NEWS

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

...

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

State of the States

Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Kano closes schools for Eid-el-Kabir

Kano governor unveils N50,000 grants for 5,200 women

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

November 18 2026
Atiku names Kashim-Ibrahim campaign chair, El-Rufai deputy

Atiku’s candidacy: ADC files 17-ground appeal

November 18 2026
FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

November 18 2026

EDITORIAL REVIEW

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

Opinion

NAFDAC mops up Europharm products nationwide

What is a Nigerian’s life worth?

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Blackouts: Broken promises, powering failure – Punch

The revenge of Band A

by The Editor
October 27 2026
0

...

2027: Wike, APC governors clash over Rainbow Coalition

Why are governors getting worse?

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

...

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.