TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Zoning controversy and restructuring debate – Punch

The Citizen by The Citizen
August 3 2020
in Public Affairs
A A
0
2023 Presidency: Aso Rock disowns Mamman Daura

Deploying the usual repertoire of brickbats, verbal acrobatics and selective back-stories, Nigeria’s elite have stepped up arguments over the thorny choice between zoning and meritocracy in selecting the next national leader. The cacophony of mutually hostile voices condemning or supporting the suggestion by Mamman Daura, a reputed northern power broker, that merit alone should determine the choice of president in 2023, reflects the regional and other centrifugal fault lines of the country that nurture the fragility of the union. They mostly miss the point: tensions over zoning and rotation of power arise solely from the current deformed political structure; restructuring the country into a truly federal system is the only road to national survival.

Hypocritically advocating merit in the choice of president in 2023, Daura neither addressed the palpable despair of ethnic nationalities who feel alienated from the system nor the rising clamour to return to the federal system that delivered development across the country in the run-up to and shortly after independence. He arrogantly said, “This turn-by-turn, it was done once, it was done twice, and it was done thrice… It is better for this country to be one…it should be for the most competent and not for someone who comes from somewhere.” He was immediately supported by the Arewa Consultative Forum, which argued that zoning and rotation were not in the 1999 Constitution. This is a deeply dishonest way of consolidating and entrenching ethnic domination. But the Presidency claims Daura was exercising his right as an elder statesman. This is an intrigue and a perfidy taken too far.

Not surprisingly, southern and Middle Belt groups have pushed back against the merit kite as a ploy by the northern elite to hang on to power. Afenifere, Ohanaeze Ndigbo, the Middle Belt Forum and the South-South Elders have pointedly recalled how the Northern elite perpetually cried, clamoured and sought at every turn to undermine the respective administrations of Olusegun Obasanjo and Goodluck Jonathan, demanding that they must not seek second terms, but stand down for northern candidates on the grounds of pre-agreed zoning arrangements. Those who vociferously swore by zoning, even threatened to “make the country ungovernable” if zoning was not respected, have today, having secured power through Major General Muhammadu Buhari (retd.), become the vocal advocates of “merit and competence”, two virtues that the regime demonstrably lacks. Buhari and his party reneged on their campaign promise to back restructuring. A panel headed by Governor Nasir el-Rufai made recommendations, but the report has been ignored.

The decisive moment, long postponed, is however closing in with possible cataclysmic impact. Haldun Çancı, associate professor of political science, Eastern Mediterranean University, North Cyprus, says Nigeria is synonymous with deep divisions, which cause major political issues to be vigorously and violently contested along the lines of intricate ethnic, religious and regional divisions. He is right. Nigeria has never been a nation and it can never be one until the contraption is reworked.

Ordinarily, merit and the ability to persuade a majority of the electorate based on programmes and policies should be the ideal qualities to win office and the very essence of democracy. But unlike other democracies where the diverse people have a sense of belonging, of shared nationhood and have put appropriate political arrangements in place to allow robust autonomy and effective self-determination for their different nationalities, Nigeria’s elite continue to live in denial of the country’s plurality. This dangerous pretence has failed to forge a common national identity among its over 250 ethnic nationalities 106 years after the British cavalierly amalgamated the diverse territories and 60 years after flag independence.

The carefully constructed federal system based on four autonomous regions that had considerable autonomy, was overthrown by the military in 1966 and since then, the country, a natural federation, has become more unitary in practice, with the 36 states as beggarly appendages of the all-powerful centre. This forsters laziness and enables some parts of the polity to dominate others, deprive them of the bulk of revenues generated in their territories and confers advantages in political offices, in the security services and the bureaucracy on a few.

It is this anomaly that informed the informal adoption of rotating the presidency between the North and the South to preserve the country’s fragile unity. This became compelling after the northern-dominated military annulled the free and fair presidential election of June 12, 1993 won by a southerner, Moshood Abiola, provoking tension and threats of a break-up.

There is little doubt that zoning, rotation and quota system deny a country the best and most acceptable, a lazy approach to solving problems, but the question is: Can Nigeria survive in its present form without zoning? Or are these latter-day advocates of meritocracy ready for a just federal system anchored along the 1963 republican constitution? This is the big worry.

The powers concentrated in the centre are so huge and those of states so hamstringing, fostering a patronage system from Abuja that alienates those kept outside the power matrix. The minorities are particularly disadvantaged. Such alienation has provoked self-determination agitation, distrust among the nationalities and violence since the end of the military rule. Apart from the economic ruins, Nigeria is ranked the world’s 14th most fragile state, and according to Olu Fasan, a Visiting Fellow at the International Relations Department at the LSE, “through the prism of the taxonomy of basic development conditions, it failed virtually all the conditions for development; it hasn’t ascended the path of prosperity because it has failed to do the needful.”

Nigerians must speak blunt truth to themselves.  Differences in culture, aspirations and worldview are disparate and wide. Over a century of shared space has not transformed a heterogeneous society to a homogeneous one because of the unjust federalism. The United States launched its independent nationhood based on the rights of the federating colonies to autonomy and became a melting pot. While other forward-thinking multi-ethnic countries continue to nurture their unions, Nigeria indulges in the delusion of forcing “unity in diversity.” It will not work.

On the contrary, it is when diverse people and states have considerable autonomy, generate their resources, compete for investments and markets and are able to actualise their aspirations, each at their own pace, that shared pride, and sense of belonging is forged. Canada’s greatness is anchored on diversity that does not deny the uniqueness of provinces like French-speaking Quebec that retain distinct identities. The seven emirates of the UAE offer a splendid example of what autonomy and true federation can accomplish for the economy and national integration.

As this newspaper has repeatedly argued, Nigeria is negotiable, a geographical expression that is definitely not cast in stone in perpetuity. It is the inalienable right of all who reside in it to forge mutually acceptable arrangements that meet their aspirations. It is equally their right to opt out of the union if they so desire based on agreed protocols. Said a Nobel laureate, Wole Soyinka, “People have the right anytime to say, ‘We want to leave this union, whatever it is’, any kind of union, politically or whatever type of union. People have the right at any time to say, ‘Let’s have a referendum in this area’, that is, for me, part and parcel of democracy. Look at what is happening in even England today – Scotland wants independence.” He is right. Singapore had to detach itself from federal Malaysia in 1965 to create a separate identity, transforming from a backwater into a highly developed market economy with the world’s seventh highest per capita income.

Daura’s statement is nothing but a brute machination designed to sow division in order to keep a section of the country perpetually in power. Much has gone wrong with Nigeria. It can get worse. The centralised, anachronistic system has failed. The United Kingdom, a unitary state, has 43 police forces for its 67.88 million people; Nigeria absurdly has a patchy one for its 200 million persons with insecurity rising to distressing and wholly unacceptable levels.

The consequences of the present contraption can be deadly. The sole agenda now should be to peacefully overthrow this unjust system that facilitates indolence; a culture of sharing instead of production, entitlement instead of contribution. Separatism is just dormant, only a political restructuring based on justice can eliminate it. Continuing with the status quo offers only the prospect of endless conflict that may eventually end in disaster.

Previous Post

As hope rises on COVID-19 vaccines – Vanguard

Next Post

UK to roll out millions of 90-minute COVID-19 tests

Related Posts

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike
Public Affairs

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch
Public Affairs

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

November 12 2026
FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries
Public Affairs

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

November 11 2026
There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo
Public Affairs

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

November 10 2026
Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch
Public Affairs

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

November 2 2026
Four states hold high-level talks to tackle insecurity
Public Affairs

Boko Haram compounding Nigeria’s case – Punch

October 23 2026
Next Post
UK to roll out millions of 90-minute COVID-19 tests

UK to roll out millions of 90-minute COVID-19 tests

Rooney questions Ferguson’s Champions League tactics against Barcelona

Rooney questions Ferguson's Champions League tactics against Barcelona

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

by The Editor
October 21 2026
0

...

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

by The Editor
September 16 2026
0

...

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

by The Editor
August 30 2026
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Enugu APC releases updated campaign council list

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

by The Editor
October 22 2026
0

...

ODDITIES

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

by The Editor
November 5 2026
0

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

by The Editor
October 26 2026
0

GLOBAL NEWS

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

...

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

State of the States

Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Kano closes schools for Eid-el-Kabir

Kano governor unveils N50,000 grants for 5,200 women

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

November 18 2026
Atiku names Kashim-Ibrahim campaign chair, El-Rufai deputy

Atiku’s candidacy: ADC files 17-ground appeal

November 18 2026
FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

November 18 2026

EDITORIAL REVIEW

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

Opinion

NAFDAC mops up Europharm products nationwide

What is a Nigerian’s life worth?

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Blackouts: Broken promises, powering failure – Punch

The revenge of Band A

by The Editor
October 27 2026
0

...

2027: Wike, APC governors clash over Rainbow Coalition

Why are governors getting worse?

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

...

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.