TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Outrage as Senate proposes death penalty for hate speech

The Citizen by The Citizen
November 13 2019
in Headlines, Latest News
A A
1
Senate probes delay in execution of N7.7bn Kagara dam
22
SHARES
734
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Senate came under fire yesterday for proposing the Hate Speech Prohibition Bill, which seeks to criminalise the offence with death as a penalty.

The bill, which passed first reading at the plenary yesterday, seeks to establish a federal government agency to check hate speech.

But senior lawyers, activists and a chieftain of Afenifere, Chief Ayo Adebanjo, condemned attempts to make hate speech a capital offence and urged the National Assembly to tread carefully on the issue.

The bill, sponsored by a former Senate spokesperson, who is now the Deputy Senate Whip, Senator Sabi Abdullahi, is entitled “National Commission for the Prohibition of Hate Speeches (Establishment etc) Bill 2019.”

Abdullahi had sponsored a similar bill in the Eighth Senate, which prescribed among others, death by hanging for anyone found guilty of the offence.

The bill Abdullahi presented to the previous Senate said an offence is committed when “a person publishes, presents, produces, plays, provides, distributes and/or directs the performance of any material, written and/or visual, which is threatening, abusive or insulting or involves the use of threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour, commits an offence if such person intends thereby to stir up ethnic hatred, or having regard to all the circumstances, ethnic hatred is likely to be stirred up against any person or persons from such an ethnic group in Nigeria.

“A person subjects another to harassment on the basis of ethnicity for the purposes of this section where, on ethnic grounds, he unjustifiably engages in a conduct which has the purpose or effect of (a) violating that other person’s dignity or (b) creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for the person subjected to the harassment.

“Conduct shall be regarded as having the effect specified in subsection (1) (a) or (b) of this section if, having regard to all the circumstances, including in particular the perception of that other person, it should reasonably be considered as having that effect.”

Part two of the 26-page bill talks about the discrimination that the bill applies to include ethnic discrimination, hate speech, harassment on the basis of ethnicity, offence of ethnic or racial contempt, discrimination by way of victimisation and offences by body of persons.

In his own reaction, human rights lawyer, Chief Mike Ozekhome (SAN), called on Nigerians to rise up against the bill, to ensure that it does not see the light of day.
He wondered when making a speech which is guaranteed as freedom of expression under Section 39 of the 1999 Constitution, became punishable by death.

Ozekhome described the bill as ill-intentioned, ill-conceived, and ill-digested to breed dictatorship and absolutism.
“An obnoxious law such as this will further drive underground and into hiding, the opposition and genuine social critics, who speak truth to power and criticise serial opaque, anti-people, corrupt and high-handed policies of government,” he added.

According to him, since the current government has been tested and known to be allergic to constructive criticisms, the bill if allowed would embolden it to clamp many Nigerians in detention.
Ozekhome’s other colleagues also warned the Senate against passing the bill, describing it as a violation of the 1999 Constitution.

Mr. Dayo Akinlaja SAN, while describing the move as weird and absurd at this age, said inasmuch as the menace of hate speech in the country should not be tolerated, there was need for caution to ensure that innocent people did not suffer.

“As much as one would not want to condone anything like hate speech the reality is that one would have to be extra careful to avoid the possibility of an abuse,” he said, adding: “If the punishment is that capital, then what happens if somebody is wrongly accused? That is rather absurd and preposterous at this age and I pray that such a thing does not come through.”

Dr. Kayode Olatoke SAN also noted that the bill violated constitutional provision on freedom of speech.
Olatoke while recalling that the matter is already a subject of litigation at a Federal High Court, stressed that the punishment is outrageous when compared with other similar crimes, which borders on law of torts.

He, however, urged the National Assembly to refrain from going further with the bill until the issue is resolved in the court of law.

Another SAN, Mr. John Baiyeshea, expressed confidence that the National Assembly would listen to public outcry.
“I’m sure the sentence will be reviewed/reduced to terms of imprisonment”, he said.
Mr. Ahmed Raji SAN called for a probe of what constitutes hate speech in the proposed law.

“I think we should start by probing into what constitutes hate speech under the proposed legislation. Notwithstanding what may constitute hate speech, the world is moving away from death penalty,” he stated.

Also, human rights activist and Executive Director of Environmental Rights Action (ERA), Dr. Nnimo Bassey, told THISDAY that it was outrageous and shameful for the Senate to contemplate a bill of that nature.

He said: “Death penalty for so called hate speech; who decides what constitutes hate speech? Our political leaders? If social media statements that have landed some Nigerians in the Gulag approximate what the drafters of this bill have in mind, then there is real threat of a dark cloud over Nigeria. The idea smacks of total insensitivity and is not expected of even the most autocratic. It is a bill with murderous intent. The National Assembly should spend its time on bills that deepen rather than constrict the democratic space. This bill should be withdrawn!”

A chieftain of the Yoruba socio-political group, Afenifere, Chief Ayo Adebanjo, said he was speechless.
“This is inconceivable in a Senate under a constitutional democracy. There is no arrest or prosecution for Fulani herdsmen’s atrocities not to talk of death penalty for culprits but for free speech. God Save Nigeria,” he said.
Also reacting, a former Special Adviser to ex-President Olusegun Obasanjo on Political Matters, Mr. Akin Osuntokun, said the new bill would amount to mindlessness.

“It is like using a bulldozer to crush a mouse. In the first place, classifying what qualifies as hate speech is problematic and prone to abuse. It will end up creating more problems than it can solve. There are extant laws that can be adapted for the same purpose. The law against defamation for instance,” he said.

Also in its reaction, the Nigeria Union of Journalists (NUJ) in a statement jointly issued by the President, Chris Isiguzo and National Secretary, Shuaibu Usman Leman, said most actions being taken in recent times were deliberately crafted to target and silence journalists.

“Safety implies freedom from danger and, in the news gathering context, safety implies protection from a range of threats journalists encounter, including arrest, legal action, imprisonment, kidnapping, intimidation and murder, amongst others. Journalists that are hitherto exposed to more danger in violent armed conflicts than in peace and stable situations, now face greater threats in a democracy like Nigeria. These threats and attacks against the media are aimed at inducing fear and self-censorship and regrettably these are the basic strategies of authoritarian regimes and not democracies like in Nigeria,” the NUJ stated. – Thisday

Share9Tweet6
Previous Post

DSS opens fire on ‘Free Sowore’ protesters, journalists

Next Post

Enugu State Governor, Rt. Hon. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi (in white) climbing a makeshift staircase to inspect the ongoing construction of the State Secretariat annex at Ede-Oballa, Nsukka Local Government Area, yesterday. 

Related Posts

Lawmaker sues Benue governor, two aides for defamation
Governance

Benue killings: Gov. Alia rejects calls for self-defence, backs community policing

June 17 2025
Former Deputy Senate President, Mantu, dies at 74
Latest News

Former Deputy Senate President, Mantu, dies at 74

June 17 2025
CDS links military saboteurs to Benue massacre
Headlines

CDS links military saboteurs to Benue massacre

June 17 2025
Benue residents protest insecurity, demand govt action
Latest News

Benue bloodbath: CDS, Police IG launch cross-border manhunt for killers

June 17 2025
PRP condemns Benue massacre, advises FG to end terrorism, barbaric killings
Latest News

PRP condemns Benue massacre, advises FG to end terrorism, barbaric killings

June 16 2025
Resurgence of killings threatens Noth Central states, food production
Headlines

Armed herdsmen gun down Benue LG residents

June 14 2025
Next Post
Enugu State Governor, Rt. Hon. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi (in white) climbing a makeshift staircase to inspect the ongoing construction of the State Secretariat annex at Ede-Oballa, Nsukka Local Government Area, yesterday. 

Enugu State Governor, Rt. Hon. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi (in white) climbing a makeshift staircase to inspect the ongoing construction of the State Secretariat annex at Ede-Oballa, Nsukka Local Government Area, yesterday. 

Go, Mugabe, Go

Philanthropy: Femi Otedola’s example

Comments 1

  1. Robinson says:
    6 years ago

    Accurate, responsible, responsive and accurate reportage. More power to your elbows.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

CAN advises Miyetti Allah to tame violent members

Imo villagers decry armed herdsmen presence in farmlands

by The Editor
June 13 2025
0

...

Imo communities decry govt takeover of farmland

Imo communities decry govt takeover of farmland

by The Editor
May 29 2025
0

...

North-Central stakeholders demand return of APC National Chairman slot

Lagos APC aspirants protest over LG primaries

by The Editor
May 13 2025
0

...

Rivers LGs urge Ibas to tackle kidnapping, herdsmen attacks

Rivers LGs urge Ibas to tackle kidnapping, herdsmen attacks

by The Editor
May 8 2025
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Police Inspectors appeal to IGP over unpaid salary arrears

Police Inspectors lament delayed promotion, appeal to IGP, PSC

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

...

Benue governor appoints TuFace Idibia as adviser

Benue governor appoints TuFace Idibia as adviser

by The Editor
April 23 2025
0

...

Gov. Diri heads PDP convention zoning committee

Gov. Diri heads PDP convention zoning committee

by The Editor
April 15 2025
0

...

NNPCL welcomes Ojulari, bids Kyari farewell

NNPCL welcomes Ojulari, bids Kyari farewell

by The Editor
April 2 2025
0

...

ODDITIES

Police Inspector loses life by accidental discharge from son

Police Inspector loses life by accidental discharge from son

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

Truck runs into Christmas procession in Gombe

Gombe perm sec, four others die from electrocution

by The Editor
June 14 2025
0

Ladies who wear leg chains are prostitutes, says Pastor Ibiyeomie

Ladies who wear leg chains are prostitutes, says Pastor Ibiyeomie

by The Editor
May 27 2025
0

GLOBAL NEWS

U.S economy: I take responsibility for everything – Trump

Trump warns Iranians to evacuate Tehran immediately

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

...

Kenya deputy police chief resigns after blogger’s death

Kenya deputy police chief resigns after blogger’s death

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

...

Trump first former U.S President to face criminal prosecution

China accuses Trump of ‘pouring oil’ on Iran, Israel conflict

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

...

Israel, Iran launch new waves of missile attacks

Israel, Iran launch new waves of missile attacks

by The Editor
June 14 2025
0

...

Bomb threat forces India flight to make emergency landing

Bomb threat forces India flight to make emergency landing

by The Editor
June 13 2025
0

...

State of the States

Enugu governor promises to immortalise music icon, Mike Ejeagha

Enugu governor promises to immortalise music icon, Mike Ejeagha

by The Editor
June 7 2025
0

...

Kano: Supreme Court reserves judgement on appeal against Gov. Yusuf’s sack

Gov. Yusuf declares Monday public holiday to mourn Kano athletes

by The Editor
June 1 2025
0

...

Ondo governor approves employment of 1,100 primary school teachers

Gov. Aiyedatiwa approves upgrade of 102 Ondo health centres

by The Editor
May 27 2025
0

...

Lagos to introduce monthly rent payment system

Lagos to introduce monthly rent payment system

by The Editor
May 15 2025
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
North-Central stakeholders demand return of APC National Chairman slot

APC flags off campaign for Lagos LG polls

June 17 2025
Nigerian varsity faces backlash over ‘no bra, no entry’ during exams

Nigerian varsity faces backlash over ‘no bra, no entry’ during exams

June 17 2025
Lawmaker sues Benue governor, two aides for defamation

Benue killings: Gov. Alia rejects calls for self-defence, backs community policing

June 17 2025
U.S economy: I take responsibility for everything – Trump

Trump warns Iranians to evacuate Tehran immediately

June 17 2025

EDITORIAL REVIEW

Benue carnage: Beyond army chief’s relocation – Punch

Benue carnage: Beyond army chief’s relocation – Punch

by The Editor
June 17 2025
0

Nigeria’s manufacturing: A call for revamp – Punch

Nigeria’s manufacturing: A call for revamp – Punch

by The Editor
June 11 2025
0

Protecting children from online predators – Punch

Protecting children from online predators – Punch

by The Editor
June 8 2025
0

Insecurity: Enough is enough – Tinubu tells NSA, Security Chiefs

Tinubu chants tiresome borrowing tune – Punch

by The Editor
June 1 2025
0

Auctioning Emefiele’s duplexes – Punch

Auctioning Emefiele’s duplexes – Punch

by The Editor
May 27 2025
0

Opinion

Tinubu cancels national broadcast, to address Nigerians from N’Assembly

Tinubu, The Audacity To Hope: Two years after

by The Editor
June 12 2025
0

...

Supreme Court affirms Mbah as Enugu State Governor

2027: Mbah, PDP and newfound political romance in Enugu

by The Editor
May 17 2025
0

...

Nigeria should emulate India’s blueprint for development

Nigeria should emulate India’s blueprint for development

by The Editor
April 21 2025
0

...

Much ado about immortalising Humphrey Nwosu

Much ado about immortalising Humphrey Nwosu

by The Editor
March 31 2025
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2024 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2024 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.