TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Zamfara: Can INEC suspend Certificate of Return without court order? – The Sun

The Citizen by The Citizen
March 29 2019
in Public Affairs
A A
0
Manual transmission of election results will give room for rigging — NBA Branch Sec.

Following the March 25, 2019 judgment of the Court of Appeal sitting in Sokoto, which set aside the decision of a Zamfara High Court that allowed the All Progressive Congress (APC) to field candidates for the March 9 elections in Zamfara, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) said it had suspended the issuance of Certificates of Return to winners of the March 9, governorship and House of Assembly elections in Zamfara State. The commission disclosed this in a notice on INEC twitter handle, @inecnigeria, posted on Tuesday.

According to the commission, “INEC has been served with the judgment of the Court of Appeal, Sokoto concerning the sponsoring of candidates by the APC in Zamfara and is studying same.

“Consequently, the presentation of Certificates of Return for the Zamfara Governorship and state House of Assembly scheduled for Wednesday 27 has been suspended.”

INEC had earlier said the APC would not contest in the state election, but a Zamfara State High Court directed INEC to accept the APC’s candidates just a few days to the elections.

However, the Court of Appeal sitting in Sokoto on Monday said the Zamfara State High Court failed to evaluate wholly all evidence presented before it before giving its verdict on the APC primaries in the state.

Justice Shaibu Yakubu who delivered the Court of Appeal  lead judgment said all evidence placed before the court had shown that the APC and others respondents did not conduct primary elections, saying it contravened the electoral law. But Zamfara State chapter of the APC, the state Governor-elect, Muktar Shehu, and other winners of the 2019 polls on the platform of the APC in the state wrote to the Independent National Electoral Commission to counter the position of the commission.

In a letter to the INEC Chairman dated March 26, 2019 written on behalf of the governor-elect and 38 others by their counsel, Magaji Mahmmud (SAN), the APC members said the Court of Appeal in Sokoto in its March 25 judgment did not “make any positive consequential order.” The lawyer said his clients “have taken positive steps towards exercising their constitutional right of appeal to the Supreme Court.”

He said his clients drew his attention to a letter written by counsel to Senator Marafa’s lawyer, Mr. Mike Ozekhome (SAN), wherein he stated, “there is absolutely no legal basis for any of the APC candidates that allegedly emerged victorious from the said sham elections to be issued with any certificate of return.”

Faulting INEC decision to withhold the APC candidates’ certificates of return, he said: “We wish to state that issues of law of this nature are regulated by an order of court or court of law and not by opinion of counsel via a mere letter from chambers.

“May we further emphasise that in the entire judgment of the Court of Appeal, there was neither a positive order made against our clients nor in favour of the appellants. Thus, it will be wrong of the commission to rely on the mere speculative letter of the appellants’ counsel at this stage when elections have already been concluded and winners have emerged. The only institution that is empowered to make a positive order in respect of this subject matter is the court of law, and no court of law has made or given an order to that effect.”

Quoting section 235 (3) of the 1999 Constitution as amended, the solicitor states, “the law is trite, right of appeal to the Supreme Court is constitutional and no court or any person can take it away by mere letter. We urge you and the entire commission to discountenance the letter of Mike Ozekhome (SAN), wherein there was no position order at the court of appeal.”

Mahmud also argued that the judgment of their Lordships, which did not contain any positive order in favour of the appellants, was supported by the provisions of section 285 (13) of the 1999 Constitution (4th alteration as amended).

Counsel for the APC candidates, in his letter to INEC, said the Court of Appeal did not make such an order.

He said: “at the risk of repetition and emphasis, it’s bad practice for counsel to resort to letter writing, thus misleading a responsible organisation like the INEC by twisting facts. The judgment of their lordships, which did not contain any positive order in favour of the appellant is supported by the provisions of Section 285 (13) of the 1999 Constitution (4th alteration as amended).

“Finally, we challenged the appellant counsel (or any other person) to show anywhere in the judgment of the Court of Appeal wherein the learned justices made a positive order in favour of the Appellants or against the Respondents.”

Senator Kabiru Marafa, Chairman of the Senate Committee on Petroleum (Downstream) and 129 others through his counsel, Mike Ozhekome, SAN, filed appealed against the judgment of the Zamfara state High Court. Respondents are Kabiru Liman-Danalhaji and 139 others represented by Mr. Mahmud Magaji as lead Counsel.

Delivering the lead judgment, which was adopted by two other justices, Tijjani Abubakar and Jamilu Tukur, Justice Tom Yakubu held that the lower court failed in its duty to properly evaluate the evidence before it. Justice Yakubu said judges have the legal power to produce judgment and reach decisions with reason, noting that in the instant case, it was not done.

“I am convinced that the lower court has failed to evaluate the evidence before reaching the decision. The Appeal Court has power in law to access pieces of evidence on appeal, which we have done. Based on available facts the respondents did not contradict the INEC evidence on conducting the said primary election.”

Justice Yakubu held that the plaintiffs, being card-carrying party members and aspirants in the said primary election, had the legal capacity to institute the suit. He added that federal, states and FCT High Courts have jurisdiction to entertain such matter.

The judges agreed that the judgment should serve as “bitter lesson” for political parties as they ought to follow legitimate guidelines and rules.

“Domestic affairs of political party activities must act within the confines of the law in dealing with party members and elections,” the judges agreed.

A Zamfara High Court recognised the primary election that produced governorship, state and national assembly candidates held by APC in the state and declared that INEC should accept the party candidates for the elections.

Unsatisfied with State High Court decision, the appellants, approached the appeal court challenging the decision on the grounds that the State High Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit among others.

The Supreme Court has attempted to define “Consequential Orders” in the case of Frederick Obayagbona & Anor v. D. Obazee & Anor (1972) 5 S .C.247 at 254. Sowemimo, J.S.C. (as he then was) delivering the judgment of the court on consequential orders after the judge had given judgment in favour of the plaintiff “as claimed,” made consequential orders, which detracted or derogated from the judgment itself said: “We think that by the very nature of the term ‘consequential’ any ‘consequential orders’ must be one giving effect to the judgment. In its ordinary dictionary meaning, the word ‘consequential’ means ‘following as a result, or inference; following or resulting indirectly.’

“A consequential order is not one merely incidental to the decision but one which necessarily flow directly and naturally there from; it is inevitable and consequent upon the decision made by the court: It must in other words give effect to the judgment already given and not a granting of fresh and unclaimed or un proven relief. It can only relate to matters adjudicated upon. Where it flowed from nothing decided, as it is in the case at hand, die subsequent orders made must be nullified.” PER CLARA BATA OGUNBIYI, JSC

Olajide Olatawura, JSC had in his lead judgment in “The Registered Trustees of the Apostolic Church Vs. Mrs. Emmanuel I. Olowoleni” held that ‘”it is a misconception to submit that consequential order made by a court must of necessity be based on the reliefs claimed.

“The basis for an order made by the court must be looked for from the evidence before the court. It is trite law that a court cannot award more than is claimed. It is equally misconceived that an order cannot be made in favour of a defendant simply because he has not filed a counter-claim.

“An order made in favour of a defendant even where he has not counter-claimed must flow from the evidence and more so if the justice of the case demands.

“In this case, the defendant agreed that a defined parcel of land was granted to the plaintiff. After the plaintiff had issued its writ and before the case was heard, it erected a wall fence enclosing not only the area granted to it but also enclosing more than was granted to it. The judge was right to have ordered the demolition of the wall fence.

“This order is a consequential order that flows from the evidence. It is not a separate head of claim expected to be found in a writ. It is covered by order 34 rule 1 of the Kwara State High Court Rules: Garba V. University of Maiduguri (1986)1 N.W.L.R. (Pt. 18) 550.”

Where a consequential order is not made, it can only be inferred by virtue of relief sought but in the very Zamfara appeal, counsel to the APC , Mahmud Magaji (SAN) said it would amount to mere speculation to infer such from the Court of Appeal judgment.

Previous Post

The tuberculosis scourge – Thisday

Next Post

Enter NFIU – The Nation

Related Posts

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike
Public Affairs

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch
Public Affairs

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

November 12 2026
FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries
Public Affairs

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

November 11 2026
There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo
Public Affairs

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

November 10 2026
Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch
Public Affairs

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

November 2 2026
Four states hold high-level talks to tackle insecurity
Public Affairs

Boko Haram compounding Nigeria’s case – Punch

October 23 2026
Next Post
Buhari signs consumer protection bill into law

Enter NFIU – The Nation

SERAP drags FG to UN over failure to end ASUU strike

Criminalising out-of-school children phenomenon - Punch

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

by The Editor
October 21 2026
0

...

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

by The Editor
September 16 2026
0

...

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

by The Editor
August 30 2026
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Enugu APC releases updated campaign council list

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

by The Editor
October 22 2026
0

...

ODDITIES

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

by The Editor
November 5 2026
0

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

by The Editor
October 26 2026
0

GLOBAL NEWS

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

...

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

State of the States

Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Kano closes schools for Eid-el-Kabir

Kano governor unveils N50,000 grants for 5,200 women

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

November 18 2026
Atiku names Kashim-Ibrahim campaign chair, El-Rufai deputy

Atiku’s candidacy: ADC files 17-ground appeal

November 18 2026
FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

November 18 2026

EDITORIAL REVIEW

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

Opinion

NAFDAC mops up Europharm products nationwide

What is a Nigerian’s life worth?

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Blackouts: Broken promises, powering failure – Punch

The revenge of Band A

by The Editor
October 27 2026
0

...

2027: Wike, APC governors clash over Rainbow Coalition

Why are governors getting worse?

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

...

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.