TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

Democracy without independence of judiciary – Punch

The Citizen by The Citizen
October 6 2019
in Public Affairs
A A
0
Democracy without independence of judiciary – Punch

Twenty odd years into the Fourth Republic, democracy is still taking baby steps. On a dispiriting note, the country’s chief jurist has reopened the long-running debate on the perceived lack of independence of the judiciary. The insight from Mohammed Tanko, the Chief Justice of Nigeria, alluding to the fact that the judiciary is still beholden to the executive arm of government for its basic operations, puts our democracy on a wobbly ground.

For a long time, there had been a notion that the judiciary could be influenced – either by government’s strong-arm tactics or by crooked litigants, particularly desperate politicians. This dispensation has witnessed the best and the worst of the bench, most often in election cases. The late Supreme Court jurist, Kayode Eso, once described some judges who handled election cases as “billionaire judges.” In a particular case, a CJN asked a president of the Court of Appeal to “arrest” the judgement of a governorship contest in a Northern state.

Determined to turn the tables, Tanko, at the special court session marking the commencement of the 2019/20 legal year, advocated a new paradigm. Hinging his position on the current template in which the bench waits interminably on the executive to survive, Tanko, who assumed office early this year, reawakened an old debate on the abridgement of financial freedom of the judiciary, which is fundamentally at the heart of its independence.

Forthrightly, he argued, “If you say that I am independent, but in a way, whether I like it or not, I have to go cap in hand asking for funds to run my office, then I have completely lost my independence. It is like saying a cow is free to graze about in the meadow but at the same time, tying it firmly to a tree. Where is the freedom? Be that as it may, when we assess the judiciary from the financial perspective, how free can we say we are?” This is sobering.

Back in August, Tanko had initially expressed strong reservations about the plight of the judiciary. He had stated, “If you say that I am independent, but in a way, whether I like it or not, I have to go and bend down, asking (for funds), I have lost my independence.” Undoubtedly, no judiciary can prove its mettle under this cloud.

In theory, there is separation of powers among the three arms of government – the executive, legislature and judiciary. This ought to cushion the interference among the arms, but with the executive controlling the purse strings, this independence is a mirage. Subtly, the executive exploits this to control the judiciary. The salaries and budgetary allocations of judges are poor, Tanko affirmed.

Although judges deserve equitable treatment, the executive makes a fanfare whenever it undertakes any project for the bench. As such, governors can heavily publicise the procurement of cars for judges. At times, when they refurbish, build or equip courthouses, they make a meal of it. In September, Ondo State governor, Rotimi Akeredolu, demonstrated this when the state presented 20 sport utility vehicles to its judges. This is belittling for the judges. The governor, his cabinet members and aides use these vehicles without any grandiose noise being made about it.

Unfortunately, this absurdity is familiar. Past CJNs had also lamented the incapacitation the judiciary was suffering. In 2013, Mariam Aloma-Mukhtar, the then CJN, expressed reservations about it. She said, “Statistics have shown that funding from the Federal Government has witnessed a steady decline since 2010 from N95 billion in that year to N85 billion in 2011, then N75 billion in 2012 and dropped again in the 2013 budget to N67 billion.”

Conversely, in the United States, once the Congress appropriates the funding for the American judiciary, the money goes directly to it after being signed off by the president. The practice there is to present the budget proposals a year ahead, just like the rest of the American budget, which gives the stakeholders the time to work on the process.

Positively, things might have eased a bit marginally under Buhari, but it is not fundamental. In March 2018, Walter Onnoghen, Tanko’s predecessor, said the independence of the judiciary was dependent on the level of funding received. “The issue of adequate funding at the state level is one of the greatest challenges confronting the judiciary of this nation,” he said.

To strengthen democracy, the executive should treat the judiciary, as it does the legislature. Already, the National Assembly has unyoked itself – and the judiciary supposedly – from the clutches of the executive with the First Alteration Act 2010. In Section 6, the Act amended Section 81 (3) of the 1999 Constitution by elevating the Independent National Electoral Commission, NASS and the judiciary to First Line Charge.

It means the funding for these federal organs go directly to them. In apparent recognition that this is lacking at the state tier, President Muhammadu Buhari, in June, assented to the Fourth Alteration Act, which grants financial autonomy to the state judiciary and legislature. (The Niger Delta Development Commission, the Public Complaints Commission, the Universal Basic Education Commission and the National Human Rights Commission are also enjoying this status.)

It is a vital step aimed at enhancing the independence of the judiciary, but obviously, it seems to be only on paper. Otherwise, the persistent complaints of financial bondage would have abated. Therefore, the three arms of government have to interrogate the reasons why the law is not working for the judiciary as it is effectively doing for NASS. Is it that the legislature is more powerful or more important than the judiciary? This cannot be the case, for the judiciary is a separate arm of government, which has the power to override both the executive and legislature, and deliver the rule of law and give justice to the common person.

Previous Post

Gov. Akeredolu presents N100,000 to each South African returnee

Next Post

The worrisome doctors’ exodus – The Sun

Related Posts

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike
Public Affairs

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch
Public Affairs

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

November 12 2026
FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries
Public Affairs

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

November 11 2026
There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo
Public Affairs

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

November 10 2026
Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch
Public Affairs

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

November 2 2026
Four states hold high-level talks to tackle insecurity
Public Affairs

Boko Haram compounding Nigeria’s case – Punch

October 23 2026
Next Post
Doctors embark on warning strike in Anambra

The worrisome doctors’ exodus – The Sun

The reintroduction of toll gates – Thisday

The reintroduction of toll gates - Thisday

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

by The Editor
October 21 2026
0

...

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

by The Editor
September 16 2026
0

...

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

by The Editor
August 30 2026
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

Benue Justice Commissioner resigns with immediate effect

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Enugu APC releases updated campaign council list

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

by The Editor
October 22 2026
0

...

ODDITIES

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

Kano woman allegedly hires men to kill co-wife’s children over inheritance

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

by The Editor
November 5 2026
0

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

by The Editor
October 26 2026
0

GLOBAL NEWS

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

US intelligence agency scrambles as classified communications network goes down

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

South Africa cautions Fani-Kayode over social media remarks

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

...

Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

...

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

State of the States

Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Kano closes schools for Eid-el-Kabir

Kano governor unveils N50,000 grants for 5,200 women

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

November 18 2026
Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

Super Eagles face AFCON qualifiers hurdle after Tanzania draw

November 18 2026
Atiku names Kashim-Ibrahim campaign chair, El-Rufai deputy

Atiku’s candidacy: ADC files 17-ground appeal

November 18 2026
FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

FG orders recovery of excess payments to university workers

November 18 2026

EDITORIAL REVIEW

ASUU, TCN, 30 others join NLC nationwide strike

Labour needs unity, not needless bickering – Punch

by The Editor
November 18 2026
0

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

Opinion

NAFDAC mops up Europharm products nationwide

What is a Nigerian’s life worth?

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Blackouts: Broken promises, powering failure – Punch

The revenge of Band A

by The Editor
October 27 2026
0

...

2027: Wike, APC governors clash over Rainbow Coalition

Why are governors getting worse?

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

...

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.