TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials
No Result
View All Result
TheCitizen - It's all about you
No Result
View All Result

The court verdict on defecting lawmakers – Daily Sun

The Citizen by The Citizen
April 4 2014
in Public Affairs, Uncategorized
A A
0

The judgement of the Federal High Court, Abuja, which declared that 37 members of the House of Representatives who defected from the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) to the newly formed All Progressives Congress (APC) had no basis to retain their seats, having dumped the party which sponsored them, has expectedly been generating ripples across the country. In the landmark verdict on March 31, Justice Adeniyi Ademola held that the lawmakers no longer had any business, morally and legally, in the National Assembly.

Consequently, he ruled that the affected legislators should honourably resign from their seats in the lower chamber of the National Assembly, having crossed to another political party while their tenure was yet to expire. Also, the court barred the House of Representatives from changing its principal officers. This, Justice Ademola ruled, was because the defecting lawmakers were not competent to vote in any process to remove its leadership, or sponsor a motion to that effect on the floor of the House. The High Court verdict is the outcome of a suit filed against the leadership of the House by the ruling PDP. The defecting lawmakers were listed as 12th and 53rd defendants.

Meanwhile, the APC has gone on appeal, while the leadership of the House of Representatives has said it would stay action on the court verdict until all the issues at stake run their full course in court. That, in our view, is the best way to go about this controversial matter, considering the fact that the defection has generated a bitter and potentially dangerous furore in both chambers of the National Assembly. It has also elicited rowdy sessions that disrupted proceedings in both legislative houses. Undoubtedly, the courts are the appropriate venues to resolve such a major controversial dispute, in accordance with constitutional provisions and acceptable democratic norms.

We, however, hope all aggrieved parties in this dispute will allow the courts to resolve the matter peacefully. This is in spite of the claims by the plaintiffs (PDP) that the judgment of Justice Ademola was executory, and not declaratory, that requires immediate enforcement.

At the heart of this dispute, and which all the parties, including the presiding judge relied upon, is the correct legal interpretation of Section 68(1)(g) of the 1999 Constitution. The section provides as follows: A member of the Senate or of the House of Representatives shall vacate his seat in the House of which he is a member if: (g) being a person whose election to the House was sponsored by a political party, he becomes a member of another political party before the expiration of the period for which that House was elected.  This provision, however, comes with a condition, that is, “provided that his membership of the latter political party is not as a result of a division in the political party of which he was previously sponsored.”

Expectedly, this section of the Constitution has been subjected to various interpretations, depending on the side of the divide to which the interpreter belongs.

But, since any declaration of a court, whether right or wrong, remains law until it is upturned by a superior court, the verdict of the Abuja court, is the position of the law for now, until the Court of Appeal rules otherwise.

Nonetheless, the Justice Ademola ruling has both positive and negative connotations for our democracy. On the positive side, the position that a legislator who crosses to another party when the party that sponsored him to office is not divided has to vacate his seat, will likely sound the death-knell to whimsical and capricious carpet-crossing in the legislative chambers. This will, perhaps, usher in some measure of stability and sanity in our legislature.

On the negative side, if the High Court verdict is upheld on appeal and becomes the position of the law, that position might further encourage impunity in the ruling party and other parties, as it will stifle dissenting voices and worsen the current lack of internal democracy that has become a common feature in virtually all the major political parties. This may ultimately not bode well for our democracy.

Altogether, we urge the Appeal Court, and the Supreme Court (if the case gets to that level), to give a definitive and well-reasoned interpretation to Section (1)(g) of the 1999 Constitution so that the controversies over carpet-crossing can be amicably and finally laid to rest.

It is instructive that until 1952 when Chief Meredith Akinloye defected from his party in the then Western Region House of Representatives to another party, upsetting the stability of politics, carpet-crossing was alien to our politics. We are inclined to believe that Sections 68(1)(g) and 109 of the 1999 Constitution were designed to remedy this. Let the courts be guided properly so that the contentious matter of carpet-crossing will be resolved once and for all so that our democracy can move forward.

Previous Post

Lagos rules out proficiency assessment for educators

Next Post

Fighting oil theft – The Guardian

Related Posts

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch
Public Affairs

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

November 12 2026
FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries
Public Affairs

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

November 11 2026
There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo
Public Affairs

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

November 10 2026
Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch
Public Affairs

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

November 2 2026
Four states hold high-level talks to tackle insecurity
Public Affairs

Boko Haram compounding Nigeria’s case – Punch

October 23 2026
Nigeria’s inflation rate falls to 15.43% in July
Public Affairs

Economic stability must become shared prosperity – Punch

October 22 2026
Next Post

Fighting oil theft – The Guardian

Punishing corrupt judges – Nigerian Tribune

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FROM THE GRASSROOTS

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

Fasoranti: Family announces Dec 17 for funeral

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

Ooni, Omisore mourn Afenifere leader Fasoranti

by The Editor
October 21 2026
0

...

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

Minister defends King’s College concession, cites infrastructure decay

by The Editor
September 16 2026
0

...

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

Lagos demolishes shanties after four die in community clash

by The Editor
August 30 2026
0

...

APPOINTMENTS

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

Makinde swears in four Oyo permanent secretaries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Enugu APC releases updated campaign council list

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

Gov. Okpebholo elevates ex-BBNaija housemate to adviser

by The Editor
October 22 2026
0

...

CJN swears in 68 new SANs

CJN swears in 68 new SANs

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

ODDITIES

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

Man stabs neighbor to death over roasted meat

by The Editor
November 5 2026
0

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

US pastor marries second wife, says monogamy unbiblical

by The Editor
October 26 2026
0

Indian man assaults truck drivers in Lagos

Indian man assaults truck drivers in Lagos

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

GLOBAL NEWS

Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

Court overturns gay sex ban in Trinidad & Tobago

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

...

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

US warns citizens against travel to 23 countries

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Russia agrees to ban recruitment of Ghanaian nationals for Ukraine war

Russia agrees to ban recruitment of Ghanaian nationals for Ukraine war

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Britain shouldn’t apologise for slave trade; Africa profited, says Kemi Badenoch

Britain shouldn’t apologise for slave trade; Africa profited, says Kemi Badenoch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

State of the States

Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

...

Kano closes schools for Eid-el-Kabir

Kano governor unveils N50,000 grants for 5,200 women

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

...

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

Delta SUBEB denies N13.4bn unspent funds claim

by The Editor
October 31 2026
0

...

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

Ogun State mulls relocation of communities over gas leak

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
2027: Tinubu repackages 2023 campaign promises in new manifesto

2027: Tinubu repackages 2023 campaign promises in new manifesto

November 12 2026
Katsina mob kills Customs officer for shooting passenger

Hisbah bans girls’ night hawking in Katsina

November 12 2026
Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

November 12 2026
Canada flags Nigeria, 16 African countries as high-risk in new travel advisory

Canada to fast-track permanent residence for 200,000 foreigners in 2027

November 12 2026

EDITORIAL REVIEW

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

Flamingos: All hail world champions! – Punch

by The Editor
November 12 2026
0

FG outlines criteria for N50k cash grant beneficiaries

Tinubu’s N50,000 relief for the vulnerable – Punch

by The Editor
November 11 2026
0

There are drug addicts, vagabonds among traditional rulers, says Obasanjo

13% derivation: Fiscal federalism to the rescue – Punch

by The Editor
November 10 2026
0

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

Nigeria’s damning food affordability crisis – Punch

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

Four states hold high-level talks to tackle insecurity

Boko Haram compounding Nigeria’s case – Punch

by The Editor
October 23 2026
0

Opinion

NAFDAC mops up Europharm products nationwide

What is a Nigerian’s life worth?

by The Editor
November 2 2026
0

...

Blackouts: Broken promises, powering failure – Punch

The revenge of Band A

by The Editor
October 27 2026
0

...

2027: Wike, APC governors clash over Rainbow Coalition

Why are governors getting worse?

by The Editor
October 13 2026
0

...

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

As we celebrate the girl-child, let us not forget the boy-child

by The Editor
October 12 2026
0

...

Plugin Install : Popular Post Widget need JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • Latest News
  • Governance
  • Business
  • Financial Crimes
  • Opinion
  • Editorials

© 2026 TheCitizen Ng. All Rights Reserved.